top of page
Search

Commercial Real Estate Contract Disputes in Texas: What Are Your Legal Options?

The Alford Law Firm
Nov 10
9 min read

Understanding Breach of Contract, Earnest Money Disputes, Commercial Leases, and Real Estate Litigation in Dallas


commercial real estate attorney in dallas tx
Commercial Real Estate Contract Disputes in Texas: What Are Your Legal Options?

Commercial real estate transactions often involve significant financial investments, complex contracts, and multiple parties. Whether you're purchasing an office building, selling commercial property, negotiating a retail lease, or investing in industrial real estate, a disagreement can quickly turn into a costly legal dispute.


What happens when a buyer backs out of a commercial real estate purchase? Can a seller refuse to complete a transaction? What if a landlord or tenant violates the terms of a commercial lease?


In Texas, commercial real estate contracts generally establish the rights and obligations of the parties involved. When those obligations are not fulfilled, the affected party may have legal options, including negotiation, mediation, or litigation.


At The Alford Law Firm in Dallas, Texas, we assist clients with real estate and business law matters, including disputes involving commercial property agreements.


Understanding your contractual rights is an important first step toward protecting your investment.


What Is a Commercial Real Estate Contract Dispute?

A commercial real estate contract dispute occurs when parties disagree about the interpretation, performance, or enforcement of an agreement involving commercial property.


These disagreements may arise during a property purchase, sale, lease, development project, or other real estate transaction.


Common disputes include:


  • A buyer failing to complete a commercial property purchase

  • A seller refusing to close after signing a contract

  • Disagreements over earnest money deposits

  • Alleged misrepresentations about a property's condition

  • Title defects or ownership concerns

  • Disputes involving inspection or financing contingencies

  • Commercial lease violations

  • Failure to meet contractual deadlines

  • Disagreements over repairs, maintenance, or property improvements


Because commercial real estate transactions often involve substantial amounts of money, even a seemingly minor disagreement can have significant financial consequences.


What Happens When Someone Breaches a Commercial Real Estate Contract in Texas?

A breach of contract generally occurs when a party fails to perform a contractual obligation without a legally sufficient excuse.


For example, a buyer may fail to provide the required funds by the closing date, or a seller may refuse to transfer the property despite an enforceable agreement.


However, not every failure to complete a transaction constitutes a breach.


The contract may contain contingencies, termination rights, notice requirements, or other provisions that allow a party to withdraw under certain circumstances.


To establish a typical breach of contract claim under Texas law, a party generally must demonstrate:


  1. A valid, enforceable contract existed.

  2. The party seeking relief performed its obligations or had a legally recognized excuse for nonperformance.

  3. The other party breached the agreement.

  4. The breach caused legally recoverable damages.


The specific facts and contract language determine whether a breach occurred and what remedies may be available.


What If a Buyer Backs Out of a Commercial Real Estate Contract?

When a buyer refuses or fails to complete a commercial property purchase, the seller's options depend on the purchase agreement and the circumstances surrounding the transaction.


For example, the agreement may allow the buyer to terminate during a specified inspection or due diligence period.


A buyer may also have a contractual right to terminate if certain financing, title, or other conditions are not satisfied.


However, if a buyer fails to close without a valid contractual or legal justification, the seller may have grounds to pursue remedies.


Potential remedies may include:


  • Retaining earnest money when permitted by the contract

  • Seeking monetary damages

  • Pursuing specific performance when legally available

  • Negotiating a settlement

  • Enforcing other remedies expressly provided in the agreement


Some commercial purchase agreements limit the seller's remedies to retaining the earnest money as liquidated damages.


An attorney can review the contract to determine whether the seller has additional options or whether an agreed remedy is exclusive.


What If a Seller Refuses to Close on Commercial Property?

A seller who refuses to complete an enforceable commercial real estate transaction may also face legal consequences.


For example, a seller might receive a higher offer after signing a purchase agreement and attempt to terminate the original transaction.


If the seller has no valid contractual basis for refusing to close, the buyer may have grounds to seek relief.


Depending on the circumstances, possible remedies include damages or specific performance.


What Is Specific Performance in Texas Real Estate Law?

Specific performance is an equitable remedy that may require a party to fulfill its contractual obligations rather than simply pay monetary damages.


In certain real estate disputes, a buyer may seek a court order requiring the seller to complete the agreed property transfer.


However, specific performance is not automatic.


Courts consider factors such as:


  • Whether the contract is valid and enforceable

  • Whether its essential terms are sufficiently definite

  • Whether the party requesting relief has performed or is ready, willing, and able to perform its obligations

  • Whether equitable requirements have been satisfied

  • Whether the remedy is appropriate under the circumstances


Because real estate is often considered unique, specific performance can be an important potential remedy in property disputes.


Who Gets the Earnest Money When a Commercial Real Estate Deal Falls Through?

Earnest money is commonly used in commercial real estate transactions to demonstrate a buyer's commitment to completing the purchase.


The deposit is typically held by a title company, escrow agent, or another designated party.

If the transaction does not close, disagreements may arise over who is entitled to the funds.

The answer usually depends on the contract.


When Might a Buyer Receive the Earnest Money Back?

A buyer may be entitled to recover the deposit when the contract permits termination under specified conditions.


Examples may include:


  • Termination during an agreed due diligence period

  • Failure of a qualifying contractual contingency

  • A seller's breach of the agreement

  • Certain title problems that are not resolved as required by the contract


The buyer must generally comply with applicable notice and termination requirements.


When Might a Seller Keep the Earnest Money?

A seller may be entitled to retain earnest money if the buyer defaults and the agreement provides for forfeiture or liquidated damages under enforceable terms.


However, the seller's right to retain the deposit is not automatic merely because the buyer failed to close.


Texas law and the specific contract language determine whether the provision is enforceable.


When the parties disagree, the escrow holder may decline to release the funds until the dispute is resolved or appropriate instructions or legal authority are provided.


What Are Common Commercial Lease Disputes in Texas?

Commercial real estate disputes are not limited to purchases and sales.


Landlords and tenants may also disagree over the terms of office, retail, warehouse, restaurant, and industrial property leases.


Common commercial lease disputes involve:


Failure to Pay Rent

A commercial tenant who fails to make required rental payments may face contractual remedies, including potential termination or eviction proceedings.


The landlord's rights depend on the lease terms and applicable law.


Maintenance and Repair Responsibilities

Commercial leases often allocate responsibility for HVAC systems, roofing, plumbing, structural repairs, and other maintenance obligations.


Disagreements may arise when the parties interpret those responsibilities differently.


Common Area Maintenance Charges

Some commercial leases require tenants to contribute toward common area maintenance (CAM) expenses.


Disputes may involve the calculation of charges, allowable expenses, or the landlord's accounting practices.


Early Lease Termination

A tenant may seek to terminate a lease before its expiration, or a landlord may attempt to terminate because of an alleged default.


Whether early termination is permitted depends on the agreement and applicable legal requirements.


Property Use Restrictions

Commercial leases may limit how a tenant can use the premises.


Disputes can arise over permitted business activities, exclusivity provisions, signage, renovations, or other operational restrictions.


Commercial leases are often heavily negotiated, and their terms can differ significantly from residential rental agreements.


A Dallas commercial real estate attorney can help review the lease and determine what contractual rights and remedies may apply.


Can You Sue Over Misrepresentations in a Commercial Real Estate Transaction?

Potentially.


Disputes sometimes arise when a buyer discovers information about a property that differs from what was represented during negotiations.


Examples may involve:


  • Property condition

  • Environmental concerns

  • Building systems

  • Zoning or permitted uses

  • Existing leases or tenant income

  • Financial performance

  • Ownership or title matters


Depending on the facts, a buyer may have potential claims involving fraud, negligent misrepresentation, breach of contract, or other legal theories.


However, commercial real estate agreements frequently contain provisions addressing due diligence, reliance, representations, warranties, and property condition.


These provisions can significantly affect the parties' rights.


A buyer's ability to pursue a claim depends on the specific representations, the contract, applicable law, and the available evidence.


How Are Commercial Real Estate Contract Disputes Resolved?

Not every commercial real estate dispute needs to proceed to trial.


Depending on the circumstances, several approaches may be available.


Negotiation

The parties may be able to resolve their disagreement by negotiating revised terms, a financial settlement, or another mutually acceptable solution.


Negotiation may help reduce legal expenses and preserve business relationships.


Mediation

Mediation involves a neutral third party who helps the parties explore a voluntary resolution.

Some commercial real estate contracts require mediation before litigation or other formal proceedings.


Arbitration

Certain agreements contain arbitration clauses requiring covered disputes to be resolved through private arbitration rather than a traditional court trial.


The scope and enforceability of the arbitration provision must be evaluated.


Litigation

When informal resolution is unsuccessful or inappropriate, a party may pursue legal action.

Commercial real estate litigation can involve contract claims, requests for damages, specific performance, declaratory relief, or other remedies.


The appropriate approach depends on the contract, financial stakes, evidence, and desired outcome.


What Damages Can You Recover in a Commercial Real Estate Contract Dispute?

The damages available in a Texas commercial real estate dispute depend on the legal claims, contract terms, and evidence.


Potential categories may include:


Direct damages: Financial losses directly resulting from a breach.


Consequential damages: Certain additional losses that may be recoverable when applicable legal requirements are met.


Liquidated damages: An amount or formula specified in the contract that may be enforceable under Texas law.


Attorney's fees: Fees may be recoverable when authorized by a statute or enforceable contract provision and when applicable requirements are satisfied.


Not every category of damages is available in every case.


Commercial contracts may also contain limitations of liability, exclusive remedy provisions, or waivers affecting recovery.


An attorney can help evaluate which remedies may be available under the specific agreement.


How Long Do You Have to File a Commercial Real Estate Contract Lawsuit in Texas?

Texas generally applies a four-year statute of limitations to many breach of written contract claims.


However, the applicable deadline depends on the specific claim and circumstances.

Other legal theories may have different limitation periods.


Contractual notice requirements and certain enforceable provisions may also affect the steps a party must take to preserve its rights.


In some situations, the parties may have agreed to a legally permissible shortened limitations period.


Waiting too long can make it more difficult to preserve evidence, enforce contractual rights, or pursue a legal remedy.


If a commercial real estate dispute is developing, seeking legal guidance early can help identify important deadlines.


How Can You Protect Yourself From Commercial Real Estate Contract Disputes?

Although disagreements cannot always be prevented, careful planning can reduce the likelihood of costly problems.


Business owners and investors should consider the following precautions:


Have contracts reviewed before signing. Commercial real estate agreements often contain detailed provisions affecting financial liability and termination rights.


Understand all deadlines. Inspection periods, financing deadlines, title objections, and closing dates can significantly affect contractual rights.


Conduct appropriate due diligence. Investigate the property's condition, title, zoning, leases, and other relevant issues.


Document important communications. Preserve written agreements, notices, emails, amendments, and other records.


Clarify remedies for default. Understand what happens if either party fails to perform.


Seek legal advice when a dispute develops. Early guidance may help avoid actions that unintentionally weaken your position.


Frequently Asked Questions About Commercial Real Estate Disputes in Texas

Can a seller back out of a commercial real estate contract in Texas?

A seller may have the right to terminate under certain contractual conditions. However, refusing to close without a valid legal or contractual basis may constitute a breach.


Can a buyer recover earnest money after terminating a commercial property contract?

Possibly. Recovery depends on the termination provisions, compliance with notice requirements, and the circumstances surrounding the transaction.


Can I sue a commercial landlord for breaching a lease?

Depending on the facts, a tenant may have legal remedies if the landlord fails to fulfill enforceable lease obligations.


What happens if a commercial tenant breaks a lease early?

The consequences depend on the lease and applicable law. The tenant may face financial liability, although contractual provisions and the landlord's legal obligations can affect the amount recoverable.


Can a court force someone to sell commercial property?

In certain circumstances, a court may order specific performance of an enforceable real estate contract. The remedy is discretionary and subject to legal and equitable requirements.


How long does commercial real estate litigation take?

The timeline varies based on the complexity of the dispute, the number of parties, court schedules, discovery requirements, and whether the parties reach a settlement.


Do I need a Dallas business attorney for a commercial real estate contract dispute?

Because commercial real estate transactions often involve significant financial exposure and complex agreements, consulting an attorney can help you understand your contractual rights, potential remedies, and legal risks.


Facing a Commercial Real Estate Contract Dispute in Dallas? Contact The Alford Law Firm

Commercial real estate disputes can place substantial financial investments and business relationships at risk.


Whether you're dealing with a failed property purchase, an earnest money disagreement, a commercial lease dispute, or an alleged breach of contract, understanding your legal options is essential.


At The Alford Law Firm, we provide legal guidance to businesses, investors, property owners, buyers, sellers, landlords, and tenants facing commercial real estate matters in Dallas and surrounding North Texas communities.


Our firm can help evaluate contractual obligations, identify potential legal remedies, and determine an appropriate strategy based on the circumstances.


Contact The Alford Law Firm to schedule a consultation and discuss your commercial real estate concerns.



Disclaimer: This article is provided for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Reading this article does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Commercial real estate laws, contractual rights, and available remedies depend on the specific facts and applicable Texas law.

 
 
 

Comments


What my clients are saying...

tranparent.png
Contact
Free Case Evaluations
If you’re facing a legal matter, our Dallas business attorney can help! 
Address 
Areas We Serve
Office Hours
We handle cases throughout the Dallas, Fort Worth area, including, University Park, Highland Park, Plano, Richardson, Allen, Southlake, Carroll, Arlington, Hurst, Euless, Bedford, Colleyville, Keller, and Grapevine, Texas.
Dallas Bar Association.jpg
Monday - Friday 9am - 5pm
Website Design and SEO by Epidemic
bottom of page